What's In A Name? The Unfortunate Baggage of Luigi Mangione

By Michael Kelman Portney

Names carry weight. They shape first impressions, establish identity, and often become an unshakable part of how the world sees someone. But sometimes, parents inadvertently saddle their children with a name that comes preloaded with associations they couldn’t have possibly foreseen—or, in the case of Luigi Mangione, chose to ignore.

Let’s be honest: if you’re of Italian heritage and you name your kid Luigi after 1985, when the Mario Brothers took over the world, you’re making a choice. Not a careless mistake, not a random accident—a choice. And it’s one that inevitably ties your kid, for better or worse, to the taller, greener, perpetually second-place brother of a mustachioed plumber duo.

Luigi in the Shadow of Mario

Luigi, as a name, is a classic. It’s as Italian as cannoli, espresso, and exclaiming “mamma mia” when things go wrong. But in the post-Super Mario era, the name Luigi comes with baggage. Suddenly, it’s not just a proud nod to Italian heritage—it’s a punchline, a callback to a fictional character perpetually living in his brother’s shadow, a name that conjures visions of overalls and green caps.

Was this a fate Luigi Mangione’s parents intended for him? Did they think about how every introduction, every classroom roll call, every job interview would immediately spark images of coin blocks and Koopa Troopas? Or did they simply shrug and say, “It’s a family name—what could possibly go wrong?”

The Mario Brothers Problem

Let’s be clear: the issue isn’t with the name itself. It’s with its cultural context. Naming your kid Luigi in a world dominated by Super Mario is like naming your daughter Elsa after Frozen—a perfectly fine name that now comes with endless jokes, Disney references, and people singing Let It Go at her for no reason.

But in Luigi Mangione’s case, the stakes were even higher. In a world where names evoke imagery and stereotypes, the associations of “Luigi” create an almost cartoonish contrast to the serious allegations against him. People aren’t just reading headlines about the “United CEO killer”; they’re thinking, Wait, Luigi? As in Mario’s brother? The result? A surreal blending of true crime and video game nostalgia that only adds to the absurdity of his story.

Why It Matters

Names matter because they frame how people perceive you before you’ve even had a chance to introduce yourself. For someone like Luigi Mangione, who now finds himself at the center of a murder case with bizarre Monopoly-like undertones, the name becomes part of the spectacle. It’s a detail too absurd to ignore, an extra layer of irony in a story already saturated with it.

If Mangione’s parents had named him something else—Antonio, Giovanni, even Mario—the public perception might have been slightly different. But naming him Luigi in a world where the name is synonymous with video game hijinks and playing second fiddle? It’s like adding a layer of unintentional parody to an otherwise dark and serious story.

The Takeaway

Parents, take note: names are powerful. They carry cultural baggage, evoke stereotypes, and, in some cases, set your kid up for a lifetime of associations they never asked for. Luigi Mangione’s story is a cautionary tale—not just about crime or Monopoly money, but about the unintended consequences of naming your child after a video game character.

Let’s just hope there isn’t a Mario Mangione out there waiting to complete the set.

---

Michael Kelman Portney blogs about the strange, the ironic, and the pitfalls of modern life at www.misinformationsucks.com.